Illustrative
Steps for Establishing , Strengthening and Operating a Sustainable Development
Strategy
A number
of steps identified during the country dialogues will assist a country in
strengthening its strategic planning process and move it in the direction
of a sustainable development strategy. These entail the identification, co-ordination
and continuous improvement of mechanisms for balancing the economic, social
and environmental concerns of multiple stakeholders. Figure 3 illustrates
the types of mechanisms that usually will be needed. The way that these mechanisms
are co-ordinated must be consistent with the principles in Box 2.
To achieve
a continuous improvement process, the mechanisms need to work together
as an action-learning system. Experience shows clearly that it is not appropriate
to think of the strategy as a linear process, i.e. design, implement, and
monitor a new strategy as separate phases. Such approaches in the past have
been ineffective, particularly when the phases have been conducted as a one-time
sequence. This has usually resulted in outcomes which, at best, have been
only partially implemented.
But there
are a number of entry points. Usually, it is helpful to take stock of what
strategic elements already exist – in terms of both vision and mechanisms.
These elements are likely to be spread amongst a variety of local and national
processes as well as one-off initiatives such as the more recent NCSs, NEAPs,
etc. Taking stock might involve national debate and analysis amongst a wide
range of stakeholders on what the different strategic approaches have to offer
and whether pre-requisites for effective strategies are in place (see section
2.2).
This would
enable a strengthened system or framework to evolve, bringing together
the best of what currently exists to improve synergies, remove inconsistencies,
avoid conflicts, and fill gaps. The result should be a broad vision of the
development objectives for the nation, and identification of the institutional
and information mechanisms through which policies, plans and supporting legislation,
procedures and actions could be developed, reviewed and harmonised. The system
would not plan everything, but would largely aim to guide change
in circumstances of uncertainty, and encourage a culture of experimentation
and innovation. This ‘framework’ approach is conducive to wide ownership,
as it can accommodate many thematic, regional, decentralised and local strategies,
some of which may have been around for some time, as well as others which
will be developed in the future.
Occasionally,
however, it may be desirable to develop a new comprehensive strategy. This
would be if stakeholders agree that a new identity is required, either because
of problems with past approaches or to signal a fresh vision and major investment
in strategy mechanisms. Care must be taken in introducing a new initiative,
as it is then all too easy to ignore existing approaches, to compete with
them and cause confusion. Even if a new identity is required, it should be
presented and promoted as building on what has been achieved so far.
Using
and strengthening national capacity is
central to a sustainable development strategy. In earlier stages it is important
to identify what skills/capacities will be needed for the various mechanisms,
what exists already, what can be achieved using them and then identifying
training options and seeking support when needed. It has been found best to
use and strengthen local capacity, not substitute for it. Such capacity includes
technical and human as well as organisational and financial resources – usually
adequate national/local resources will be available to keep a strategy process
alive if there is enough understanding about its importance. As processes
which promotes continuous improvement, strategies themselves are an efficient
way to build capacity.
The whole
framework should operate as a knowledge system, bringing together information,
analysis and monitoring and communication.
Figure
3. Mechanisms contributing to a sustainable development strategy
Explanation
This
figure visualises suggested basic elements of a system for developing and
implementing a strategy for sustainable development. The system should encourage
and facilitate the building of consensus in society about a vision, goals
and objectives for sustainable development (the centre circle). It should
provide a coordinated set of information and institutional mechanisms to deliver
these (the satellite boxes). In establishing such a system, there is a need
to look for precedents, recent trends and improvements in mechanisms beyond
branded and packaged approaches that might provide examples on how to make
progress – adhering to the basic principles set out in Box 2
Bearing these
points in mind, illustrative steps for co-ordinating and developing strategy
mechanisms are offered in Box 23.
Box 23: Illustrative
steps for developing, co-ordinating and continuously improving strategy
mechanisms
The following steps
apply particularly to strategy development tasks, i.e. those needed
to establish the mechanisms by identifying elements that work, improving/building
on them, and/or initiating new elements if necessary. But the same or
similar tasks are then iterative during strategy co-ordination and continuous
improvement:
- Take stock of,
and analyse, current strategies:
-
Establish a
mandate for the strategy (handed down or generated). The
more this represents domestic public demand with high level support,
rather than external, the better (e.g. a mandate from prime minister
or president is better than from international bodies).
-
Identify the
stakeholders of an integrated sustainable development strategy,
and outline their (potential) responsibilities, rights and relations.
- Establish a
secretariat (or strengthen an existing one) acceptable to these
stakeholders, with powers and resources to co-ordinate the steps outlined
in this box, and the continuing strategy mechanisms.
- Establish
the rules governing the strategy process:
- Debate
how all decisions will be made and agreed
- Co-ordinate
means for negotiation of trade-offs and conflict management.
- Establish
the mechanisms to be used in the strategy:
- Identify
mechanisms used by existing strategies (see Figure 3).
- Review
achievements of these mechanisms in terms of synergies, clashes
and gaps, and their outcomes
- Identify
what is required to improve synergies and plug gaps
- Establish
regular debate and analysis across sectors and between
levels:
- Regular
periodic thematic, national, decentralised and local stakeholder
fora (round tables, hearings, workshops, etc) to reach
and improve consensus on basic vision, goals, principles, system
components, pilot activities, targets and responsibilities,
and to review progress.
- Communication
and information systems to ensure regular flows of information
concerning sustainable development between stakeholders and
between fora. This will include development of key information
products such as ‘state of environment and development’ reports,
policy briefs and news releases.
- Analysis
of the sustainability of the outcomes of policy, legal, institutional
and financial changes.
- Establish
a schedule of implementation of the strategy process – determine
activities, responsibilities, capabilities and resources needed, and
their timing.
- Establish
ongoing monitoring and accountability mechanisms, notably:
- Development
and review of sustainability indicators and the collation and analysis
of baseline information on the environmental, social and economic
issues.
- Participatory
development and review of standards/codes of practice that can be
used in regulations, incentives and voluntary mechanisms.
- Identifying
and encouraging innovative processes to promote the culture of action-learning.
- Agreeing
possible roles for independent monitoring or ‘watchdogs.
- Prepare
a budget for the strategy process, secure financial resources,
and allocate them to agreed uses in a timely and accountable manner.
- Establish
what are residual trade-offs at any stage and operate rules
for negotiating them and managing conflict.
|